Table of Contents

Table of Contents

New Jersey Juvenile Rights Are Sacred

New Jersey Supreme Court issues "appropriate Procedure" in Juvenile Cases

New Jersey juvenile rights are much better than the protections offered by the Federal Constitution.

The law in NJ states: “wherever possible … no child should be interviewed except in the presence of his parents or guardian”.

More specifically, “the product of interrogation of a juvenile under 14 is not admissible in the absence of a parent or legal guardian “unless the adult was unwilling to be present or truly unavailable.” State v Presha, 163 NJ 304,  2000.

What was decided?

In a recent decision NJ juvenile rights have received more clarity and more protections.

In State in the Interest of A.A.  the New Jersey Supreme Court issued a policy for how police handle juvenile interrogations.

Specifically, the Court wrote: ““The police should advise juveniles in custody of their Miranda rights—in the presence of a parent or legal guardian—before the police question, or a parent speaks with, the juvenile. Officers should then give parents or guardians a meaningful opportunity to consult with the juvenile in private about those rights… That approach would enable parents to help children understand their rights and decide whether to waive them… If law enforcement officers do not allow a parent and juvenile to consult in private, absent a compelling reason, that fact should weigh heavily in the totality of the circumstances to determine whether the juvenile’s waiver and statements were voluntary.””

The Court has taken bold steps in making certain that NJ juvenile rights are clear to law enforcement.


Facts of the case

A.A. was 15 years old when the police detained him on murder charges.

His mother went to visit him in the police station holding cell. The only thing she was told was that her son “shot someone.”

Five police officers were in the room within 10 to 15 feet of A.A. and his mother while the two spoke.

A detective testified that he overheard the conversation and that the mother began to cry and left the room.

A.A. never received his Miranda.

The Family Part judge admitted the statements upon finding there was no “police interrogation or its functional equivalent,” and therefore no Miranda warnings were required.

In concluding that the juvenile’s statements were both inadmissible and were not harmless at the juvenile’s hearing, the Supreme Court repeated prior holdings that interrogation includes not only direct questioning but also “any words or actions on the part of the police … that the police should know are reasonably likely to elicit an incriminating response,” and in the case of a juvenile, that an admission “must be voluntary, in the sense not only that it was not coerced or suggested, but also that it was not the product of ignorance of rights or of adolescent fantasy, fright or despair.”

New Jersey Supreme Court's Conclusion

In closing, the New Jersey Supreme Court wrote: “We can envision nothing more appropriate or fair in the administration of juvenile justice. Independent of the right to counsel, a juvenile is entitled to meaningful support and assistance from a caring parent or guardian before saying anything to a police officer, as well as anything that can be heard or overheard, while in custody.”

important tip: Be Patient! You will Get Your Day in Court

The best NJ Juvenile Rights lawyer will tell you that when you talk to a police officer, everything you say can & will be used against you.
Do not try to explain your story to a police officer. There is always time for that.
If you make a mistake while you are telling your story to a police officer, this becomes evidence against you.

More Practice Areas

More Helpful Articles

Plea Bargains What Are They & How Do They Work?

Plea bargains run our criminal justice system. 90% of cases are settled by way of plea deals. When you’re charged with a crime, your lawyer will negotiate a plea bargain. But is a plea bargain your only way out?

Plea Bargains What Are They & How Do They Work?
Read More
NJ PTI: Everything You Need to Know in 5 Minutes!

Everything you need to know in five minutes
Think of Pre-Trial Intervention (PTI) as your ONE & ONLY Get-out-of-Jail-Free card. It’s the QUICKEST way to be done with your Felony arrest.

NJ PTI: Everything You Need to Know in 5 Minutes!
Read More
How To Get Criminal Charges Dismissed

Getting your criminal charges dismissed is possible. If you’ve been arrested, then you’re interested to know how your criminal lawyer can get your charges dismissed. Of course, you understand that you are innocent until proven guilty.

How To Get Criminal Charges Dismissed
Read More
NJ Felony Charges: 5 Steps To Start Fighting Back!

New Jersey felony charges are termed “Indictable Offenses”. These are the most serious charges that you can face. If you plead guilty, or are found guilty, the judge has no choice but to sentence you to prison.

NJ Felony Charges: 5 Steps To Start Fighting Back!
Read More
  • Juvenile Lawyer Near Me

If you would like to meet with us to discuss your case, we offer FREE consultations.

About the Author

Attorney Alan G. Peyrouton

Attorney At Law

Mr. Peyrouton is a Criminal Defense Attorney located in Hackensak, NJ.

His articles in the areas of Criminal Law have been published in The New Jersey Law Journal.

He is a distinguished author, trial attorney, and has had the privilege of arguing before the New Jersey Supreme Court.

Prior to becoming an attorney, Mr. Peyrouton was a world-class, competitive tennis player.

He is perfectly fluent in Spanish.